Tuesday, September 18, 2018

Report from yesterday's meeting

Mike Gapes MP has said he cannot make the 17th November and so we have cancelled this meeting.

Also, Mike has said he does not wish to Andy organise the planned meeting and so Bob Archer, the Secretary of Redbridge Trades Council will take over organising the meeting to hold the NHS to account for breaking their promise to review the closure of King George A&E.  

Bob will write further updates about this meeting at 

Wednesday, September 12, 2018

Planning meeting: midday 17th September Redbridge Central Library

Come and join Bob Archer, the secretary of Redbridge Trades Council and I for an informal discussion about how we make the 17th November save King George A&E meeting a success.

Venue: Cafe at Redbridge Central Library in Ilford

Time: midday 17th September

Saturday, August 18, 2018

Photo from earlier today

Local parties were invited to bring banners along, just one did so today. I expect other parties will come on board will come for the November 17th rally at Redbridge Town Hall. Ashley Gunstock, a senior Green party member was away on holiday.

Those attending covered a range of parties and none at all.

The poster says 

"Build the cross party & multi-faith campaign to save our A&E" 

Getting as many people together on the 17th November must our next task to persuade NHS managers to honour their November 2017 commitment to review the King George A&E closure plan.

Bob Archer secretary of Redbridge Trades Council says:

"Save King George Hospital campaigners leafleted in High Road Ilford and held a photo-shoot in front of Redbridge Town Hall on Saturday 18 August to kick-start the campaign for a rally inside the building on Saturday 17 November. It has become clear that the local hospital trust is still looking to close A&E on the site. Local trade unions and politicians urgently need to get active in the Save King George hospital campaign."

Wednesday, August 15, 2018

Writing to Councillors re photo shoot for 18th August & Freedom of Information

This will go to Councillors in Havering, a similar version will go to Redbridge & B&D


Dear Councillors

Photo shoot re plan to close Cedar Chemotherapy unit at King George Hospital & transfer to Queens

Date: Saturday 18th August Midday
Location: Outside Redbridge Town Hall


Writing to you on the 9th August appears to have led to BHRUT issuing a statement about the Cedar unit which is the end of this email (1)

This statement is welcome, but it still leaves the questions I asked of BHRUT unanswered which are:

1 – Why were Councillors not consulted about the planned closure?

2 – Why is BHRUT breaching their own clinical services strategy, available on their website, to keep outpatients at King George?

3 – Why is BHRUT breeching their commitment to keep care close to home in their clinical services strategy?

4 – Will BHRUT provide full disclosure of the documents relating to the planned closure, especially the proposed staffing to patient ratios and the impact to the Queens car park?

5 – Can Joe Fielder, the BHRUT chair, provide an assurance that on his watch, no further cuts to services will take place until elected representatives and the public via board papers have been notified and consulted in advance?


The BHRUT statement implies the proposed closure of the Cedar unit is an improvement to their service. BHRUT also claim that the proposed closure of King George A&E will also improve the service to residents. The evidence is clear at that closing emergency admission beds at King George as preparation for the A&E has led to a worse service at both King George and Queens (2).

This begs the question of whether closing outpatient departments at King George will lead to a worse outpatient service at Queens.

BHRUT provide no evidence to support their claim that the reduction in service from five days to two days at the Cedar unit is a service improvement. So I hope you will agree that a five day a week service for the Cedar unit should be restored and the plan to close the unit abandoned.

If you cannot make the photos shoot, any quotes from Councillors for the press would be very much appreciated.

Requesting your help with regarding BHRUT statistics on Time to admit & Sepsis, Pneumonia, Urinary Tract Infections

On 29th March I wrote to BHRUT to information about the above statistics:

My argument for the information to be released relied upon was:

 
Page 35 at paragraph 4 (c) of a recent Redbridge Council Health Scrutiny working group report chaired by Wes Streeting MP suggests BHRUT keeps this information. I request BHRUT use the same method of calculation used to produce this information Wes Streeting's group.
 
 
I realise this information comes at a cost. However, yesterday the Redbridge Health Scrutiny committee called for two extra wards to be opened at BHRUT. It to be proportionate for the costs of this information to be allowed for the public to judge whether additional funding for our NHS is required “ end of quote

On 1st May 2018 BHRUT wrote to me to supply the following (3)

For the month of February

a) The average time from being seen by a doctor to a decision being made to admit: 

295 minutes 

b) The time taken to arrive at a diagnosis for the following conditions:

Pneumonia: 664 minutes
Sepsis: 673 minutes
Urinary tract infections: 446 minutes

However, since then in an email dated 7th August (4) BHRUT refuse to provide further monthly information and cast doubt upon the information supplied on 1st May 2018. I am seeking to lodge a “decision review”, should you be supportive of this information being provided each month I would be grateful if you could send me an email and I would use it as a reason for BHRUT to disclose the information I seek.

A recent Panamora concerning the conviction of Dr Hadiza Bawa Garba and the tragic death of Jack Adcock shows why it is important for sepsis and life threatening conditions to be diagnosed quickly.

Tracking these conditions each month is an essential part of monitering what is hapeening at King George and Queens and I would be grateful for any help you can provide on this point.



Regards


Andy Walker

(1) BHRUT statement on Cedar unit below


Dear Andy,
 
Following your recent email to several councillors and the questions you’ve raised on social media I thought it might be helpful if I provided you with the following information.
 
In June we consolidated the number of days over which we give chemotherapy treatment in the Cedar Centre at King George Hospital from four days to three. Since then, due to changes in demand and thanks to careful management of patients, we have consolidated this further to two days, ensuring we use our resources as efficiently as possible.
 
We are hugely proud of our recent track record in cancer. Just this week we hit the national standard for 12 months in a row. We’ve also introduced cutting edge technology to our radiotherapy departments that is putting us on track to being one of the most advanced cancer centres in the NHS.
 
We are always looking at ways to improve our serviceand are already liaising closely with Scrutiny Committee colleagues around any potential future proposals.
We will engage and involve our patients and public in any changes we would like to make to improve the quality of their care and their experiences at our hospitals,as we routinely do.     
 
All the very best.
 
Peter

(2) Various articles at http://savekinggeorgehospital.blogspot.com/ over the years. An example is here http://savekinggeorgehospital.blogspot.com/2018/07/council-attack-bhrut-over-king-george.html

3 The BHRUT email extract is below of 1st May 2018 disclosing Sepsis and other information




4 BHRUT refuse to disclose information below on 7th August:








Tuesday, August 14, 2018

Monday, August 13, 2018

BHRUT need to supply more information about what is happening at the Cedar Unit

I wrote to Havering Councillors and put up a Faceboook video about the proposed closure of the Cedar cancer unit at King George. Got a reply from BHRUT, at end of post, not good enough so will keep pushing for more information.

Dear Councillors
 
As a consequence of Sandie Smith writing on my Facebook page I put up a tweet on Monday morning to ask BHRUT whether it was correct that the Cedar Chemotherapy unit at King George Hospital was now only open two days a week when it used to be open for five.
 
The BHRUT website said yesterday it was still open for five days.
 
Sandie also said the Cedar unit was going to be completely closed and patients sent to Queens.
 
When I asked BHRUT recently on twitter as to whether it was correct that Sterile Services at King George had been closed and moved to Maidstone, they replied within 24 hours to confirm the closure.
 
By Wednesday afternoon, and despite me chasing, BHRUT had ignored my request from Monday. So I phoned the Cedar unit to be told it was only open two days and it is planned to closed and patients sent to Queens.
 
 
to persuade BHRUT to issue a statement about what is going on with the Cedar unit, but as yet I continue to be ignored. If you are supportive perhaps you could take whatever action you thought best to get BHRUT to issue a statement.
 
The conduct of BHRUT raises questions such as:
 
1 – Why were Councillors not consulted about the planned closure?
 
2 – Why is BHRUT breaching their own clinical services strategy, available on their website, to keep outpatients at King George?
 
3 – Why is BHRUT breeching their commitment to keep care close to home in their clinical services strategy?
 
4 – Will BHRUT provide full disclosure of the documents relating to the planned closure, especially the proposed staffing to patient ratios and the impact to the Queens car park?
 
5 – Can Joe Fielder, the BHRUT chair, provide an assurance that on his watch, no further cuts to services will take place until elected representatives and the public via board papers have been notified and consulted in advance?
 
On a separate, but related issue, a report by Deloitte about BHRUT was published earlier this week. The press reporting of this left out a key Deloitte recommendation to stop BHRUT meeting monthly. This will undermine our local democracy and make it more difficult for us to hold BHRUT to account. I encourage you to lobby for BHRUT to meet monthly in public.
Regards
 
 
 
Andy Walker
 
120 Blythswood Road IG3 8SG
 

Dear Andy,

Following your recent email to several councillors and the questions you’ve raised on social media I thought it might be helpful if I provided you with the following information.

In June we consolidated the number of days over which we give chemotherapy treatment in the Cedar Centre at King George Hospital from four days to three. Since then, due to changes in demand and thanks to careful management of patients, we have consolidated this further to two days, ensuring we use our resources as efficiently as possible.

We are hugely proud of our recent track record in cancer. Just this week we hit the national standard for 12 months in a row. We’ve also introduced cutting edge technology to our radiotherapy departments that is putting us on track to being one of the most advanced cancer centres in the NHS.

We are always looking at ways to improve our services and are already liaising closely with Scrutiny Committee colleagues around any potential future proposals.
We will engage and involve our patients and public in any changes we would like to make to improve the quality of their care and their experiences at our hospitalsas we routinely do.     

All the very best.

Peter